DIY Diva
Welcome GuestLog in  Register
Online: 0 members and 131 guests.
Keyword 
Vickie Schaffeld-Holbrook
Tuesday, September 22, 2009 - 10:05 am
Image not available.
Photo by: HGTV.com
Image not available.
Photo by: hgtv.com

Fu For Thought raves about Antonio's special. Fans of Reality TV

Hey, did you watch Antonio Ballatore's first show after winning Season 4 of HGTV's Design Star earlier this month?

I did, and so did a couple of my fellow Design Star fans. Antonio says he won't deliver the typical HGTV fodder.

"It's going to be shot different. We're going to go about it a totally different way. I'm going to try to bring something new to the whole network, something different than you've ever seen before in design television," Antonio told Heather Warlick-Moore at NewsOK.

Antonio's first show — a special one-hour special where he makes over an 800-square-foot repo home he had purchased before he even made it on Design Star.

Antonio called on his buddies to help with various aspects of the four-room — five-day — challenge.

If you expected a traditional, classy host, you were probably disappointed because he's not going to aim for that.

HGTV didn't want another host like all the others. They chose a crass, sexist set designer dude who is proud of his image. Need examples?

He bought a birthday cake for one of the guys, cut it with a skill saw and served out messy portions from his hands.

The 40-year-old man has no problem saying on camera that he loves to shop for furniture because the sales clerks are usually cute and he can flirt with them.

He actually pushed up his T-shirt sleeves as he talked to the clerk to reveal more of his colorful tattoos. He showed off the bedroom as the place where the magic is made.

I didn't think it was funny, but I'm sure many did. Antonio did and said the unexpected. That's what we should expect: A lot of shock TV.

Remember the infamous pink geese and ducks on the white wall in the first challenge? He hung a pink duck on the wall and mentioned the "pink duck moments" several times as he shopped and talked to the audience or his buddies.

It was one of his glory moments during the competition and he's going to milk that for all that it is worth.

As for the overall finished "Antonio Project," I have some likes and dislikes. I rarely love everything. I usually want to steal an idea or two. The same goes for this makeover.

Here's what I liked:

  • The aluminum backsplash made from pieces of heavy aluminum cut up and pieced back together in up and down directions.
  • A very shiny black, simply designed U-shaped kitchen that looks out to the dining/living room. Slivers of aluminum broke up the top and bottom rows of black kitchen cabinets.
  • A big 17th century Spanish chair - the throne - from his father, coupled with a smaller chair from the same period for the opposite end.
  • A heavy 4x8 dining room table for the big overstated chairs. However, the dainty adjustable-height bar stools (on one side of the table) didn't seem to fit proportionately.
  • The fireplace fascia made from what looked liked small river pebbles and flecks of glass. The mantle was thin and understated.
  • The claw-footed bathtub, the simple three-headed shower - I assume there will be some kind of curtain to contain the water.
  • The lacquered painted bedroom furniture shot with metal flakes.

What I didn't like:

  • The gaudy airbrushed custom headboard - a 9-foot sombrero girl - "the girl I'm going to be waking up with every morning" - with huge silver roses on each side.
  • The four tiny photos of his friend's work didn't belong in the bedroom. They would have been fine in the bathroom.
  • The garish art work in the dining/living room. Note: Antonio's father painted them, so I know they hold sentimental value. But they seemed to be thrown on top of the mantel with his other collectibles. At least one of them would have looked better in the bedroom.
  • The tiny bar setup on a small piece of furniture on the far side of the room. That needs to be near a sink and some working space.
  • The sexist approach in his "hosting."

Finally, in the "what about" category:

There's no real living room. But what do you expect for an 800-square-foot home? Antonio chose the large dining room table to highlight his father's chair. That was cool. He plans to use that table as a gathering place for entertaining or holding meetings. That's OK in my book.

Here's what one couple reported back to me after they watched the Sunday night show.

"By the way, we watched Antonio's show tonight," the woman wrote. "Bill thinks he did awesome. I am more biased, can't help it. But he did do a good job, I truly think he has a good TV personality, I just can't tolerate his design style. Bill thinks he will do good, and I think he is probably right. I just wish his (Antonio's) style wasn't so out there, but it will probably fill a niche somewhere."

She's right. We can't all love the same hosts.

I for one, still miss Johnny Carson on the late night circuits.

Bookmark and Share

Comments:

My family, also, has decided not to watch "Divine Design" with Candace Olson, Vern Yip's "Deserving Design" and Geneveive Gorder's "Dear Geneveive" because, as Scott stated above, none of them can pick a Design Star. I don't mean to keep bashing Antonio, but his sexist remarks offended my daughters and I cannot stand to even look at him.
Mark Podmore - 11:53 AM, Wednesday October 21, 2009
Well, I'm going to have to say I really enjoy Antonio and think he has a lot to offer. His designs are very different and unique. Face it seeing the same old thing, done over and over again, has really dulled HGTV's network. Dan will be hosting an online show and that is right where he belongs at the moment. After he gains more experience, perhaps he'll be ready for television. I really think he's fortunate to have been given an opportunity to be voted in by the fans. Past seasons of Design Star only had 1 winner, therefore Dan should really count his blessings.
Sidlange - 8:22 AM, Saturday October 3, 2009
"It's going to be shot different. We're going to go about it a totally different way. I'm going to try to bring something new to the whole network, something different than you've ever seen before in design television..." This is clearly HGTV talking "through" Antonio. Good luck, HGTV, America isn't buying. Don't even get me started on my thoughts about AB. His personality turns my stomach, his design talent beyond questionable. There's nothing to like. As you say, we can't all love the same hosts, but as one HGTV blogger humorously commented: "if I wanted Attila the Hun, I'd watch the History Channel, NOT HGTV." At least you'd be sure to get a quality program.
ShowMe - 7:34 PM, Thursday September 24, 2009
As promised, I did not watch Antonio's show nor will I, not even to find fodder to prove HGTV made a TERRIBLE mistake with this man. HGTV doesn't care if we don't like him if we watch, so I'm not going to. Not just to prove a point, but because I genuinely cannot stand his behavior. His sexist attitude is inexcusable. What does HGTV mean he's a "fresh new voice?" His kind of voice used to be commonplace. Where I worked I had to walk past men like him and deal with the leers, the whistles, and the held-up fingers rating how good (or not so good) I looked. And in case you think I'm an unattractive woman and that's just sour grapes, I'm not. I'm not drop-dead gorgeous, but I wasn't hard on the eyes either. This behavior was rude and crude and uncomfortable to be around. Finally workplace laws,education, and time tamed these situations and women no longer have to live with this (or at least it's much less prevelant). Most men realize women are not sex objects there for their entertainment. Returning to this prehistoric, dragging a woman by her hair behavior is beyond mind-boggling. It's nauseating. Every time a commercial comes on where Antonio says "it's gonna be like nothing you've ever experienced on HGTV" I say outloud, yeah, you're right about that. I am so angry about this. Who does he think he's impressing with this chest-beating, serving up cake with bare hands, sexual remarks? Does anyone genuinely find that amusing? I mean, really? HGTV can count me OUT when it comes to Antonio's show or future episodes of Design Star. I think one of the requirements for being on the show ought to be you have to at least be able to walk upright and not have your knuckles dragging the floor! I mean, pul-lease. Add to that Antonio's design "talent" is sporadic at best and this whole thing is a nightmare. I am not going to say Antonio doesn't have a good design idea now and again because he does, but the ideas are hit and miss, don't begin to compare to Dan's razzle dazzle, never miss, amazing designs, and with Dan we don't have to deal with the in-your-face, it's-all-about-me attitude. If that is what HGTV was looking for, no wonder they didn't select Dan b/c he's about as far from that kind of crude behavior as fire is from water. All I see of Antonio are ads for his show and it is obvious from those that exactly what I thought would happen has happened. He took his "win" as free rein to be even more "out there" than he was before. HGTV has unleashed something they're going to have a hard time reining in. Oh well, they brought it on themselves.
dana - 6:05 PM, Thursday September 24, 2009
Thank you so much for your commentary. For the most part, I believe you are right on! I too watched his show in an attempt to be fair and give him a chance. This is what I walked away with: I felt here are key elements of design in Antonio's work that are sorely lacking. There was no cohesiveness in style, color, theme, color connect, scale, repetition, texture and countless other design fundamentals. No way would I ever hire or recommend Antonio as a designer. However, I would hire him as a framer~ that's his niche. His kitchen was nice. I liked his Stainless back splash. However, he's inconsistent in this design concepts and shows poor execution. One of the first rules of good design is that you must first know the rules of design in order to know how to break the rules! It's horribly obvious that Antonio is flying by the seat of his pants and clearly doesn't have a clue what those design principals are~ admittedly so. If HGTV wants this show to succeed, they need to give him a crash course in design execution and tone down his sexist delivery. It's offensive.
ru4us - 3:01 PM, Thursday September 24, 2009
I only watched to see "what was not shown on Design Star". Not enough included in the episode to count. As far as the Antonio show goes, what I expected, nothing of interest to me. All the people looked like they needed a hot, long bath. There is nothing, nothing, nothing about Antonio that I find interesting or note worthy as designer, if you can even call him a designer. I will not be watching his show at all. Furthermore, I will not watch Vern, Candace or Geneveve's show either. Since they so obviously can not pick a design star designer I can't accept them as a designer worth my time either.
Scott - 10:50 AM, Thursday September 24, 2009
Vickie- Thanks for all the updates and your unbiased comments about Antonio. You're a much better woman than I!!! Although I felt Dan was the better choice of the two, I was actually open-minded to Antonio's win and purposely stayed up Sunday night to watch his "big reveal." What a train wreck! Was it the "dating show" or a make-over show. . .hard to tell! I agree that the kitchen had its highlights--but that was it--period. The bedroom looked cheap, and whether it was his taste or not, the Sombrero girl over the bed was tacky and should have remained a tattoo on his body! I kept hoping the show would get better but it never did. I was actually embarrassed for him. Flipping houses your entire life does not put you in the same league as a skilled architect or designer for that matter. Sunday night was Antonio's opportunity to shine--to show the world what he was made up of and that he was deserving of the title Design Star and he blew it. It was by far the absolute WORST makeover I have seen by any Design Star winner in its history. HGTV has their work cut out for them!
Sharron - 10:01 AM, Thursday September 24, 2009
I feel Antonio lacks style and has no taste. I am a man and he embarrased me withhis sexist remarks and extremely garish tastes. The entire "Antonio Project" was a display of his "in your face and I don't care" attitude. He pushed the macho stuff too far because most men watching HGTV don't appreciate that disgusting spectacle Antonio diplayed.
Mark Podmore - 9:42 AM, Thursday September 24, 2009
Love the way you have kept us up on all the inside stuff Vickie, thank you. I agree with you on almost everything, but I could not stand that bedroom furniture...but you are right, the back splash was fabulous.
Machele - 3:32 PM, Tuesday September 22, 2009


If you Log in or Register you will not be required to fill this out each time you comment.
Name:
Email Address: Will not be published.
Comment [max. 5000 chars.] Character Count:

Vickie Schaffeld-Holbrook
Vickie has worked at the Idaho Press-Tribune since 1979. In her free time, she loves to share her ideas when it comes to home and garden.
Idaho Press-Tribune on Facebook
IPT Community Calendar
<< >>
SMTWTFS
01020304050607
08091011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930          
Submit your event - FREE!
http://www.linkedin.com/pub/4/955/980
Blog Admin login
Username:
Password: